Comments on eCube: Should IDs Have Skills in Areas Other Than Writing...

Dear Ka Kite,I agree with your perspective. I unde...

2008-05-20T17:49:00.000+05:30

Dear Ka Kite,

I agree with your perspective.

I understand that writing and design skills are the ones that are required the most by an ID; however the point I was trying to make was that these are not the "only skills" required by an ID. Along with these, there are other important skills (as mentioned in the post) that are required by an ID.

Regards,
Sonali

I completely agree Shiny! Thanks for adding in mor...

2008-05-20T17:42:00.000+05:30

I completely agree Shiny! Thanks for adding in more "substance" with real-life examples to this.

I agree with you Sonali. IDs should have a holisti...

2008-05-20T11:54:00.000+05:30

I agree with you Sonali.

IDs should have a holistic picture because they design the entire product and should not be limited to writing. We, the IDs, own the overall design of a product so we should know about all aspects that impact the product design.

To strengthen my case, following are some advantages (top of the mind actually) I have experienced knowing a bit about construction and media:
• Strategize better during storyboard: Knowing how the final product will appear and behave helps in strategizing and writing instructions accordingly. For example, in the Autodesk project, we use the content data model to develop content (essentially we need to write small chunks of information considering reusability). This content is then moved to an LCMS, where each chunk of information is treated as a separate element. A single-parse methodology is used on the LCMS to generate different outputs. In this situation, it becomes very important to understand how the LCMS works before we develop content.
• Minimize dependencies on other practices: If an ID can perform tasks, such as simple graphic editing, creating software-based simulations, and creating simple graphics (elements are provided), the communication, iterations, and waiting time can be minimized to a great extent. For example, there are some effects that need to be applied to application screen shots to indicate they are cut. Sending this request to a media person and explaining requirements can become tedious.
• Communicate ideas and requirements effectively: I can communicate the visualization and functionality requirements for a frame/page better.
• Perform better product reviews: IDs can raise issues knowing the limitations and even recommend fixes (at times work around) to get the product to behave and appear the way it was designed.
• Communicate better with client: These days most of our client contacts are people who are experts in multiple practices while we have separate practices and experts within these practices. It is awkward in a call where there is a one-many ratio of participants; the many participants from our side are required not for expert opinion but to answer simple questions. Personally, I think we should have single person leading a call and handling questions from our end too. If inputs from an expert are required, then the expert can speak up or we can get back later with our responses.

Kia Ora Sonali.I agree with the need for the ID to...

2008-05-18T11:45:00.000+05:30

Kia Ora Sonali.

I agree with the need for the ID to have a holistic view to the whole project. While I also agree that other skills than writing/design are required, I get the impression that what your saying is that these specified skills are somewhat less important than the rest.

Having worked with qualified ID’s who were patently deficient in their writing/design skills I can vouch that they were not really capable of imparting much knowledge through their work.

In fact many of those who were deficient in these areas could not even understand the need for the writing/design skills. Without very close supervision they were incapable of producing anything of use to the learner.

Ka kite
from Middle-earth

I completely agree with Sonali. As an ID is involv...

2008-05-15T16:25:00.000+05:30

I completely agree with Sonali. As an ID is involved in a project from the initial stages, he/she has to do a lot more than just writing. Additional knowledge of graphics, construction is only going to help the ID perform better.